Monday 18 April 2022

'THE LEGACY': 26: ‘The Scholar Speaker’ Dr LAKSHMI NARAYAN ‘SUDHANSHU’ & KRISHNA BALLABH SAHAY (17/04/2022)

DR LAKSHMI NARAYAN 'SUDHANSHU'
(15 DECEMBER 1906- 17 APRIL 1974)

KRISHNA BALLABH SAHAY 
(31 DECEMBER 1898-3 JUNE 1974)




Dr Laxmi Narayan Sudhanshu was born on 15 December 1906 in an aristocratic family at Rupaspur Purnia. He was intelligent since childhood and had a knack for reading and writing. Keeping this in mind, his father Shri Dhanpat Singh got him enrolled in the school at Purnia. Later he was sent off to Bhagalpur for secondary education. He completed his higher education at Banaras Hindu University. From the very beginning, he was interested in literature. Many of his works were published during college life.

After completing his studies Dr Lakshmi Narayan Sudhanshu joined the college at Deoghar as a teacher and later on was elevated to the post of Principal of the Govardhan Sahitya Mahavidyalaya under Hindi Vidyapeeth, Deoghar in the thirties. Dr Sudhanshu later joined the Congress and became active in the Quit India Movement of 1942. He was elected to the Bihar Legislative Assembly in 1946. He became the President of the Bihar Pradesh Congress Committee in 1950. However, Dr Lakshmi Narayan Sudhanshu was primarily an educationist and a litterateur and even during the freedom struggle and thereafter as a member of Assembly and later on as Speaker of Bihar Vidhan Sabha his love for literature remained intact as he continued to contribute to the field of Hindi literature. 

Krishna Ballabh Babu began his literary career as the Chotanagpur correspondent of the Calcutta based 'Amrit Bazar Patrika' during his student life. Later Krishna Ballabh Babu started publication of a magazine named 'Chhotanagpur Darpan' from Hazaribagh which continued for many years. Similarly, Dr Laxmi Narayan Sudhanshu started the publication of a weekly named 'Rashtra-Vani' in 1939. From 1952 to 1956, Dr Sudhanshu started the publication of the monthly literary magazine 'Avantika' in Hindi. In 1955, he established a cultural organization in Purnea called the Kala Bhavan, where cultural and literary programs were organized regularly. In 1961, Dr Sudhanshu was nominated as the President of Bihar Rashtrabhasha Parishad. In the 1962 elections, Dr Sudhanshu won the Assembly elections from Dhamdaha on a Congress ticket and was unanimously elected as the Speaker of the Bihar Legislative Assembly. As the Speaker of the House Dr Sudhanshu played an important role in upholding the dignity of the House and always carried out his responsibility impartially. During the proceedings of the Bihar Legislative Assembly, there were many occasions when he succeeded in checking the rancour among members and normalizing the atmosphere with his eloquence and literary acumen. He always took care that there should be no disturbance during the proceedings of the House. Dr Sudhanshu used to go out of his way to seek the cooperation of members of the House to maintain the dignity of the house and often used his literary acumen to lighten the tense atmosphere from blowing out of proportion.

During this period i.e. 1962-1967 Dr Sudhanshu came in contact with Krishna Ballabh Sahay. Their love for literature and their association with various newspapers and periodicals over the years brought these two stalwarts near. Krishna Ballabh Sahay took over as the Chief Minister of Bihar in 1963. Dr Sudhanshu was the Speaker of the House. This was a unique moment in the history of the Bihar Legislative Assembly when the Chief Minister of the State was a scholar of the English language and the Speaker was a scholar of the Hindi language. During debates, Krishna Ballabh Babu used to quote extensively the couplets by renowned Hindi poets such as Tulsidas, Bihari, Surdas, as well as English litterateurs such as William Shakespeare and William Wordsworth with equal ease and eloquence. Dr Sudhanshu often joined him in such debates in a scholarly manner.

There is an interesting incident when Dr Sudhanshu corrected K. B. Sahay’s Hindi. The Bihar Appropriation Bill 1965 was being debated in the House and Krishna Ballabh Babu was speaking in Hindi while throwing light on the importance of the Panchayat System. Putting his point before the House, Krishna Ballabh Babu said- 'In my opinion, the meaning of Panchayati Raj is to awaken the people's power in the countryside. The welfare of the local people can be done only through Panchayat Raj. For example, in Ranchi, the tribal population is 60-65% but there are only ten wells for them. We have to see that justice is done to tribals and backward castes and this is possible through Panchayati Raj. If we do something wrong then we are criticized so it is our responsibility to do justice to them’.

Dr Laxmi Narayan Sudhanshu was taken aback to hear 'if we do wrong things' and could not stop himself from interrupting Krishna Ballabh Sahay. He intervened to correct K.B. Sahay- ‘The Hon’ble Chief Minister should not say 'we do something wrong'. Instead, you should say 'when we make mistakes.' (आप ऐसा नहीं कहें कि हम गलत काम करते हैं। आप यह कहें कि जब हमसे गलती होती है।’)

Krishna Ballabh Babu thanked the Speaker for correcting his Hindi-'Hon’ble Speaker Sir, I am not a Hindi scholar, so there may be a few mistakes in my language. I thank you for correcting me. What you say is correct’. K. B. Sahay then went ahead to complete his speech-‘There are Harijans and Adivasis in our state. The government has to see that justice is done to all. Therefore Panchayati Raj has been established in four districts and gradually it will be implemented in more districts’.

Dr Laxmi Narayan Sudhanshu was a man of few words. He used to be precise in his address and his style of oratory was such that the members used to get convinced by his directives. Thus Dr Sudhanshu was able to conduct the House smoothly without any adjournment. A similar incident happened on 2nd February 1966. Krishna Ballabh Babu was presenting the ‘Report of the Annual Financial Statement of the State of Bihar for 1966-67’ in the House and he was reading out from the printed report. The Report is an account of the activities and achievements of various Ministries of the Government and the report is replete with statistical figures highlighting the government’s achievements. Naturally, members find such speeches quite boring. To break the monotony, some members broke into a conversation in a hush-hush tone. Dr Laxmi Narayan Sudhanshu was presiding over the House. He drew the attention of the members towards the dignity of the House and appealed to them to pay attention to the speech- 'Members are requested to maintain peace. If Members do not consider it necessary to listen to the printed speech, even then it is necessary to maintain silence’.

To break the monotony, Krishna Ballabh Babu sought the Speaker’s permission to speak without referring to the printed text- 'Hon’ble, Sir, if you so permit, I can also speak extempore without referring to the printed text because even I find it difficult to read out from a printed text'. The House was amazed at this request. Was it humanly possible to remember all the facts and figures of such a vast report? This meant that Krishna Ballabh Babu had not only read the entire report but had memorized every single figure in it- such was the level of intelligence of K. B. Sahay.

Even Dr Laxmi Narayan Sudhanshu was left surprised at the Chief Minister’s request. Since convention did not allow such relaxation, therefore the Hon’ble Speaker rejected Krishna Ballabh Babu's proposal citing the convention–'The practice of reading printed speech is followed, so you are requested to read out of the printed speech only'.

Taking a jibe at the Hon'ble Speaker’s decision, Kapil Dev Singh, the Praja Socialist Party MLA from Burhee commented that 'compared to the printed speech, the extempore speech of Hon'ble Chief Minister Krishna Ballabh Babu is better'. Krishna Ballabh Babu reassured Kapil Dev Singh that-'You will get many opportunities to hear me speak extempore during this budget session'. In fact, to listen to the fluent style in which Krishna Ballabh Babu spoke and occasionally quoted lines from poems of Hindi and English poets was always a pleasant and learning experience for the House.

During his Chief Ministership, when Krishna Ballabh Babu visited Purnia, he participated in the programs of 'Kala Bhavan'. In a photograph taken on the occasion, Krishna Ballabh Babu and Dr Sudhanshu can be seen interacting with each other in a happy mood, indicating the intense literary understanding between them.

Krishna Ballabh Babu lost the assembly election in 1967. He resumed the publication of 'Chhotanagpur Darpan' from Hazaribagh. Even though Krishna Ballabh Babu had lost the election, he remained in touch with Dr Sudhanshu and they used to discuss issues of common interest including literature. In 1969, Dr Sudhanshu was nominated as the President of Bihar Hindi Granth Academy. During their lifetime, Dr Sudhanshu and Krishna Ballabh Babu were associated with many educational institutions. Purnea College, Deoghar Vidyapeeth and Govardhan Sahitya Mahavidyalaya were some of the institutions of which Dr Sudhanshu was a founding member. Similarly, Krishna Ballabh Babu strived for the promotion of education. He established many schools and colleges in Chotanagpur, some of which were also named after him. Krishna Ballabh Babu was re-elected to the Bihar Legislative Council on 27 May 1974. But Dr Sudhanshu did not live to hear this good news. He died on 17th April 1974. Krishna Ballabh Babu also died in a highly controversial motor car accident on 3 June the same year. Thus within a span of a couple of months, Bihar lost two of its illustrious sons who made a mark in the field of literature and were also freedom-fighter, educationists and a leader.

[Credits: (i) National Archives, New Delhi, (ii) Documents of the proceedings of the Bihar Legislative Assembly)